Singing Masks

I tried 10 different masks for singing (some marketed towards singers and some not) and here’s what I found:

First off- I am not an affiliate of any of these companies- I am just a voice teacher who is passionate about vocal health and accessibility. With that said- every singing mask has different benefits and drawbacks to them and trying them all out can get expensive- so I did that part for you. I tested each of these masks for:

What I tested for:

1. Comfort

2. Resonance

3. Price

4. Fit

5. Protection

6. Customer Service and Speed

Here are the masks that I tested:

1. Surgical Mask (Can be found online or in drugstore/grocery store)

2. KN95 Mask (Can be found online or in drugstore/grocery store)

3. 3-D Fabric Masks (Amazon Link) —-> Approx. $4 a mask

4. Broadway Relief Singer’s Mask https://www.broadwayreliefproject.com/singersmask ——> Approx. $25/mask

5. Singer’s Mask on Amazon (click here) ——> Approx. $22/mask

6. TMF Singer’s Mask (NATS Choice) https://stores.inksoft.com/nats/shop/home ——> Approx. $10-$15/mask

7. Midura Design’s Singer’s Mask https://miduradesigns.com/3d%2Fsinger-mask-shop —-> Approx. $15/mask

8. DCBL Mask (Marketed toward Speakers) https://www.dcblmasks.com/ —-> Approx. $15-$20/mask

9. Mask extender (Amazon Link) —-> Approx. $8 per pack of 10

10. Plastic 3-D Frame for Mask (Amazon Link) —-> Approx. $10 per pack of 10

Too Long Didn’t Read Version (TLDR) My top choice is DCBL X-1 Mask https://www.dcblmasks.com/

They are a little pricey ($15-$20 per mask), but they are the most comfortable, best protection and best resonance in my opinion. I also can breathe really easily in them without problem. If you are able to invest I’d suggest buying a few of these to switch between when one is in the wash. Also a great options for teachers or other voice users. Everyone has different bone structure and preferences so I’ve included what I like and dislike about the other mask options.

I’m going to rank my top picks for each category and then elaborate a little on each option.

• Comfort

• DCBL X-1 Mask

• Midura Design

• 3-D Mask

• Mask Extender and/or 3-D Frame can really help make any mask more comfortable

Least Comfortable: Broadway Relief Project Singer’s Mask

• Resonance

• DCBL X-1 Mask

• TMF Mask

• Broadway Relief Mask

Worst Resonance: Surgical Mask without extender or frame

• Price

• Fabric mask or surgical mask with extender and frame (trade off: some comfort- especially jaw tension)

• TMF Singer’s Mask (trade off: worse customer service and longest wait time)

Most Expensive: Broadway Singer’s Relief

• Fit (somewhat depends on face shape)

• DCBL Mask (somewhat adjustable)

• Midura mask (comes in different sizes)

• TMF (comes in different sizes)

• Protection

• DCBL X-1 Mask

• KN95 (Trade off in resonance)

• TMF Mask

Least Protection: Any mask that does not fit you! You should have a seal around your whole mouth! Always check fit for your masks! And make sure you can move your jaw without it falling off! Also look for layers! Is it single layer or 3 layer? If it’s reusable how easy is it to wash? Will you be able to regularly wash it or “quarantine” it between washes?

• Customer Service and Speed

• DCBL X-1 Mask

• 3-D Fabric Masks

• Broadway Relief Mask

Worst Customer Service: TMF- it took months to receive my masks, and even then my order was wrong.

1. Surgical Mask (Can be found online or in drugstore/grocery store)

• This is the one most of us are accustomed to using

• Benefit: easily accessible and inexpensive, also disposable

• Downsides: hard to move jaw and lips, not best resonance, tends to collapse when inhaling, neck tension

• Ways you can make this better: use a mask extender and/or 3-D Frame. They are inexpensive, reusable and can be paired with any mask for more room to room, less inhalation collapsing and to try to reduce neck/jaw tension.

2. KN95 Mask (Can be found online or in drugstore/grocery store)

• This provides the most safety and is fairly accessible

• Not great for resonance, BUT you could pair this with a microphone to amplify your sound

3. 3-D Fabric Masks (Amazon Link) —-> Approx. $4 a mask

• This does not have the most protection, but it is definitely one of the most cost effective options

• Just make sure it fits you properly

• You can also pair this with the 3-D frame and mask extender

4. Broadway Relief Singer’s Mask https://www.broadwayreliefproject.com/singersmask ——> Approx. $25/mask

• Honestly this one is my least favorite for the following reasons:

  • Most expensive

  • Clunky and painful (hard wire rim)

  • Gets incredibly hot while you are singing

  • Not as good resonance as the others

5. Singer’s Mask on Amazon (click here) ——> Approx. $22/mask

• This mask is okay and fine in a pinch

• Not the best fit or protection

6. TMF Singer’s Mask (NATS Choice) https://stores.inksoft.com/nats/shop/home ——> Approx. $10-$15/mask

• This mask was cited in a study as being one of the better singer’s masks on the marker (protection wise)

• It is one of the most cost effective solutions

• Fit and comfort are good

• The resonance is fair

• My customer service experience was appalling. It took months for me to receive my order- and when I got it the order was wrong. I still have not been refunded or sent the corrected masks I was promised two months ago. I would not recommend them for that reason.

7. Midura Design’s Singer’s Mask https://miduradesigns.com/3d%2Fsinger-mask-shop —-> Approx. $15/mask

• Pretty good design and sound

• There’s so nose bar to help with glasses not getting fogged up (but that might be something you like)

• Easy to breathe, but the frame tends to collapse during deep inhales

• Different sizes is a nice feature, helps with fit

8. DCBL Mask (Marketed toward Speakers) https://www.dcblmasks.com/ —-> Approx. $15-$20/mask

• This is my top pick in just about every area

• The customer service is great, the fit is perfect, there is 3-layer protection and easy washing.

• Soft and comfortable

• Best resonance in any of the masks

• One of the only singer’s masks that don’t make you look like a duck

9. Mask extender (Amazon Link) —-> Approx. $8 per pack of 10

• Great option for people who don’t like mask behind the ears

• Great option for people dealing with tension in neck/jaw from masks

10. Plastic 3-D Frame for Mask (Amazon Link) —-> Approx. $10 per pack of 10

• inexpensive option to help with mask collapsing during inhalation

Singing Isn’t Cancelled

Most singers know that when they perform there are dangers. Singing is deeply emotional and spiritual- when you bear your soul to the world it’s vulnerable and scary. Singers are weary of vocal injuries and the physical toll that being a vocal athlete can have. However, most of us did not think that singing could be a contributor to a pandemic.

NATS Fight the Fatigue Campaign

#FightTheFatigue is an initiative started by the National Association of Teachers of Singing (NATS). NATS has been working tirelessly to provide resources for teachers, administrators and singers about how to keep singing alive in a time where singing needs to be reinvented. Check their website out for resources about singing safely during COVID-19.

Here are some ways that The Interlude Community has been fighting the fatigue and keeping music alive:

Covid Caroling:

We drove to 50 different houses to bring cookies, Christmas cheer and socially distanced caroling in December of 2020. It was a wonderful and safe way to continue to connect with music.

Virtual Lessons:

Before the shutdown I was coincidentally already experimenting with online lessons. Thankfully, this allowed for a fairly smooth transition when all of my lessons went virtual in March. With time, research and tweaking I am loving the new format. It allows me to see exactly where and how my students are practicing. It gave students the opportunity to get over practicing anxiety in their homes and for many the familiar space helped shy students to shine! (Keep your eye out for future posts about the benefits and drawbacks to online lessons and posts about optimizing online lessons).

Revamping Home Recording Studios:

We’ve been updating our recording equipment as well as helping others update theirs! We’ve been making videos and audio recordings for Churches, Special Events, Communication by Captivation, and other musicians looking for instrumental and vocal tracks.

Virtual Concerts:

My husband and I have held a variety of virtual concerts (both live and pre-recorded. Some have been just the two of us and others have been with our students. We’ve also been able to have students participate in virtual competitions such as the Hal Leonard Competition and the NATS Boston Competition.

Below is our Christmas Vespers concert we created for the church Devereux is the Worship Arts Director for Community Congregational in Billerica, MA. We arranged each of the songs ourselves for this reflective service which combined songs and scriptures.

Spotlight Series:

We’ve been working to showcase the work of different musicians and educators during the COVID-19 pandemic. So many artists have been innovative and inspiring and we want to highlight to amazing things people are doing. Follow us on Facebook and Instagram to get spotlight updates about music happening right now.

How are you keeping music alive? Comment below with what you have been working on, and any links, or social media accounts to follow with your work 🙂